Sermon for the Last Sunday after Pentecost, Year A (11-22-26)
The Rev. Drake Douglas
Readings: Ezekiel 34:11-16, 20-24; Psalm 100; Ephesians 1:15-23; Matthew 25:31-46
If you've left church these past few weeks feeling a little bruised by the readings, I understand.
Ten bridesmaids wait for a bridegroom, their lamps burning low, and five of them find the door shut. Three slaves are handed a fortune, and one is cast into the outer darkness. And this morning the nations are gathered before the throne of glory and divided, sheep on one side, goats on the other.
Read one after another, these parables can seem to point to a God marking up a ledger, just waiting for us to slip up, and taking a little too much pleasure in it.
But I don't believe that's what's really at the heart of these stories. So this morning I want to come at them by another road, through another story that has helped me understand judgment more than any commentary ever has: a short book by C.S. Lewis called The Great Divorce.
It begins in a grey town. It's always drizzling there, always on the edge of an evening that never quite arrives. The town is enormous and mostly empty, because the people who live there can't stand one another, and they keep quarrelling and moving further and further apart.
And there's a bus stop in that grey town. Anyone may get on the bus. No one is turned away. When they do board, the bus lifts out of the grey and comes to rest at the edge of a countryside so bright and so solid that the passengers, by contrast, look like ghosts. The grass is so real it hurts their feet. A single leaf is too heavy for them to lift.
And down from the mountains come the people who live there. Lewis calls them the Solid People. Each has come for one particular ghost, often someone they knew and loved on earth, and each brings one invitation: “Stay. Walk with me. It will hurt at first, but your feet will harden, and you'll grow real enough to belong here. Come up into the mountains.”
Then we watch how each ghost responds to the invitation.
One ghost meets someone who once worked for him, a man he considered beneath him, now standing there, radiant and solid. He can't bear it. He wants his rights, what he is owed. He will not stay where that man was welcomed first, so he gets back on the bus.
There's a clergyman, and I confess this one finds its mark, who is invited to come and see the face of God. He wonders whether there'll be scope for his gifts, perhaps a theological society up the mountain eager to hear his latest paper. He's spent so long thinking interesting thoughts about God that he no longer wants God. He goes back on the bus.
There's a mother whose love for the son she's lost has slowly curdled into possessiveness. She may see him again, but only if she'll first seek God more than she seeks to possess her boy. She refuses. She would rather hold on to her grief and her claim on him than receive him as a gift.
And then there's a man with a small red lizard on his shoulder, its mouth at his ear. It whispers to him constantly: some appetite, some old habit, something he's ashamed of and has long since stopped noticing. A burning angel comes to him and asks, “Would you like me to make him quiet?”
“Of course,” says the man. But when he realizes the angel means to kill it, he flinches. “Oh, I didn't mean that. That's a bit drastic.”
The angel asks again, gently: “May I kill it?”
“Not today. I'm not feeling well. Perhaps another time.”
The lizard leans in and whispers that the angel is lying, that whatever kills it will kill him too.
And still the angel asks: “May I?”
“Couldn't it be done gradually? A little at a time?”
“Gradually won't help,” says the angel. “May I?”
“It's going to hurt.”
“I never said it wouldn't hurt. May I?”
And at last, trembling, the man whispers, “Get it over with. Damn and blast you. Go on, can't you?”
The angel takes hold of the lizard, and in his agony the man cries out. But then the man becomes solid, bright and huge, and the lizard becomes a great stallion, silver and gold. The man climbs onto its back, and together they ride up into the mountains.
Nothing of who he truly was is lost. Only the thing that had kept him a ghost.
Here's what strikes me every time I come back to this story. No one is thrown out of the beautiful countryside. The bus runs both ways, endlessly. The door stands open. And still, most of the ghosts go back to the grey town.
They go back to the grey town because staying would mean setting something down: a grievance, a reputation, a grip on someone they love, an insidious lust always whispering in their ear.
They'd rather keep the thing than enter the countryside.
That's what judgment looks like in Lewis's story. It isn't God hunting for a reason to bar the door. It's God telling us the truth about what we cling to, and then asking, the way the angel asked, whether we'll hand it over.
“May I?” Christ asks us. “May I take it from you? To make you more real?”
The bright country isn't cruel. It's simply real, and only what is real can abide there.
In this light, the last three weeks' parables read differently to me. The foolish bridesmaids aren't simply shut out by a petty bridegroom. They assumed the waiting would cost them nothing, and they arrive at midnight with empty lamps.
The third slave isn't condemned for losing money. He never lost a cent. He buried the gift because he was afraid to hand it over to its greater potential.
And this morning, the sheep and the goats. There's one more encounter in Lewis's story that speaks to today's Gospel.
A great procession comes down out of the mountains, with music and dancing and children scattering flowers. At its center walks a woman so radiant that the narrator assumes she must be someone tremendously important. She isn't. On earth her name was Sarah Smith, and she lived an ordinary life in an ordinary London suburb. No one ever wrote her name down. But every boy who crossed her path she loved like a son, every lonely person found a mother in her, and even stray animals followed her home. All of them walk with her now. In that country, she is one of the great ones.
That's what a sheep looks like. Not someone who earned a reward, but someone whose life had been poured out so long on the hungry and the overlooked that mercy had become the very shape of who she was.
She has come to meet one ghost: her husband, Frank. He arrives in a strange form, a tiny, shrunken figure holding a chain, and on the end of the chain a tall, theatrical actor who does all his talking for him. All his life Frank has used his wounds as leverage. “Did you miss me?” he asks Sarah. “Were you lonely without me? How can you be happy while I suffer?” He has come to make her joy pay for his misery.
And she won't let it. With enormous tenderness, she refuses. She will not let his self-pity hold her joy for ransom. She keeps loving him, keeps inviting him, keeps telling him he can let go of the chain. And each time he turns back to the actor and the speeches, he grows smaller, until there's nothing left but the performance of perpetual victimhood.
That's what we often look like as goats. Not monsters, but people so wrapped up in our own story that we never really see anyone else.
The hungry, the naked, and the prisoner are all around us, and we're busy rehearsing our own grievances. Love is held out to us to the very end, and it's held out still. What we won't do, as goats, is let go of the chain.
But here's the mercy in it. Heaven doesn't let misery have the last word. Sarah's joy is not sacrificed on the altar of Frank's self-pity, and in the end, no one's will be. God is not cruel to the one who refuses. But neither will God let the refusal of grace hold the kingdom hostage.
This is Christ the King Sunday, and it is fitting. The one on the throne in Matthew 25 is no stranger. He's the one who was hungry, and naked, and in prison.
The Good News today is that judgment is real. And judgment is real because the kingdom is real: more solid than we are, more real than we've yet become. None of us will walk into that countryside still carrying our lizards, our grievances, our fear, or clutching our curdled love.
But the King, the one who asks us to unclench our grip, who offers to kill our lizards, is the same one who comes down the mountain to meet us, who knows us by name, and who keeps asking, for as long as it takes:
May I? May I?
Amen.
The characters, scenes, and some dialogue in this sermon are drawn and adapted from C.S. Lewis, The Great Divorce (1945).

