Sermon for the Twenty-Fifth Sunday after Pentecost, Year A (11-15-26)
This Sunday's Gospel is a tough one. A master calls a slave "wicked and lazy" and throws him into "the outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth."
Happy Sunday.
This parable is often preached as a lesson in productivity, but I don't think that's all that's here. This is also a story about fear. And if we keep reading past where the lectionary stops, I think it becomes a story about the cross.
Let's begin with the talent. A talent wasn't a skill. It was a weight of silver worth something like fifteen to twenty years' wages. Even the one who received "only" one talent was handed a sizeable chunk of change.
As jarring as it is to hear, our translation is right to call these people slaves rather than servants. They likely owned nothing. Yet the master places a fortune in their hands.
Matthew's word for what the master does is paradidōmi. It's translated "entrusted" here, but it means to hand over: to place something into someone else's hands, and let go of it.
Remember that for later.
So the master leaves, and the slaves are on their own. Two of them put the money to work and double it. When the master returns, he greets each of them with the same words: "Well done, good and trustworthy slave… enter into the joy of your master."
Then the third comes forward: "Master, I knew that you were a harsh man… so I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground."
I was afraid, and I hid. It's not the first time we hear that in scripture. Those words echo Adam in the garden of Eden, when God comes looking for him: "I heard you coming, and I was afraid, and I hid myself."
In all fairness, we should give this man some credit. In a world where masters really could be harsh, his fear was not irrational. And by most standards, what he did was responsible. Nothing was stolen. Nothing was lost. Every coin came back.
But nothing was risked, and so nothing was gained.
That is the fear at the heart of this story. It isn't greed. It's self-preservation, and just as in our own lives, it masquerades as prudence.
If we're being honest, we hold back our time, our attention, our money, our love, because we're afraid that if we give ourselves away, there won't be enough left for us.
C.S. Lewis saw this clearly in The Four Loves. To love anything at all, he wrote, is to be vulnerable. If you want to make sure your heart is never broken, you have to give it to no one. Wrap it up and "lock it up safe in the casket or coffin of your selfishness." And there, he warns, it won't break. It will harden. It will become unbreakable, impenetrable.
That is what happens to the buried talent. The third slave keeps it perfectly safe, and he loses it anyway.
Jesus said it plainly: whoever would save their life will lose it. But he also goes on to say: whoever loses their life for my sake will find it.
Martin Luther King Jr. understood that. The night before he died, he preached on the parable of the Good Samaritan. The priest and the Levite who passed the wounded man, he said, were asking, "If I stop to help this man, what will happen to me?" rather than, "If I do not stop to help this man, what will happen to him?"
The next day, King was killed in Memphis. He did not save his life. Few would say he lost it.
But we haven't dealt with the master's answer yet, and we have to. He doesn't argue with the slave. He says, "You knew, did you, that I reap where I did not sow, and gather where I did not scatter? Then you ought to have invested my money with the bankers."
That's a tough line, and I'm not going to smooth it over. Just as it's painful to inhabit a first-century world where slavery was condoned, it helps to remember what kind of story this is.
A parable isn't a code, where every character stands for someone and we only need the key. Jesus tells parables using all manner of complicated characters: an unjust judge, a dishonest manager. Something of God may show through those figures, but it's unwise to draw a straight line from them to God. Parables exaggerate. They shock. The scholar C.H. Dodd said a parable leaves us in just enough doubt to "tease [the mind] into active thought." Parables are built to catch us, not to settle things for us.
So notice what the master actually holds against this slave. It isn't that he failed to double the money. It's that he wouldn't let it out of his hands at all. He wouldn't hand it over to anyone.
Whether the master really is who the slave says he is also remains unsettled. Is God harsh, reaping where God did not sow? The story leaves that question hanging, and I think it does so on purpose, because Matthew begins to answer it in the next chapter.
Right after a collection of challenging parables that seem to settle who's in and who's out of God's rescue plan, Jesus cuts to the chase: "The Son of Man will be handed over to be crucified." Paradidōmi. The same word.
And Matthew keeps using it. Judas asks the priests what they will pay him to hand Jesus over. The priests hand him to Pilate. Pilate washes his hands and hands him over to be crucified. Handed over, handed over, handed over.
The master in the parable placed everything he had into hands that might not be trustworthy. Now God does the same with God's own self: into the hands of a friend who betrays him, leaders who envy him, and a crowd that cries for his execution.
God does not bury the talent. God does not play it safe. God does not protect God's self.
It's as if God becomes a fourth character in this parable: the one who risks everything and loses it all. By every measure the world uses, Good Friday is a total loss, after all.
Which brings us to the outer darkness.
As Jesus hangs on the cross, Matthew tells us that "darkness came over the whole land" from noon until three. It's the same word used in the parable: skotos.
What exactly did Jesus mean by the outer darkness? I don't know. But I do know this: it isn't empty. The one who was handed over went into that darkness himself, so that no one would be left alone there. Not the frightened slave. Not you, and not me.
The one who went into the darkness doesn't stay there, and he doesn't leave us there either. On the far side of the cross, God is still handing things over, even to people who buried what they were given the last time. So the question this parable leaves us with isn't whether we did well enough with the last talent. It's what we'll do with what's in our hands now.
That is the good news in this hard parable. We don't give ourselves away so that God will finally be generous to us. We give ourselves away because we can trust God with our need.
So whatever you've buried to keep yourself safe, you can dig it up. Not because you're brave, but because you've been entrusted, because he was handed over first, and because joy is waiting.
Handed over, for you.
Handed over, to you.
Amen.

