Sermon for the Feast of All Saints, Year A (11-1-26)

The Rev. Drake Douglas

Matthew 5:1–12


On Tuesday, a lot of us will walk out of a polling place with a little sticker on our shirts that says I VOTED. Notice the pronoun: I voted, not "we." And honestly, that's how most of us were taught to think about voting, as a matter of my voice, my taxes, my interests, and my side.


But Sunday's Gospel invites a different question. Not simply how shall I vote? but who is my vote for? To answer it, we have to look at who Jesus was talking to.


Right before this passage, Matthew tells us the crowds came from Galilee, the Decapolis, Jerusalem, Judea, and beyond the Jordan, bringing their sick and suffering with them. They were peasants living under Roman occupation. Not one of them had a vote, or could petition Caesar, or had a representative to call.


And Jesus sits down, in the posture of a teacher, and he doesn't tell them what to do to become blessed. He tells them who already is.


Blessed are the poor in spirit.

Blessed are those who mourn.

Blessed are the meek.

Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness.

Blessed are the merciful.

Blessed are the peacemakers.

Blessed are the persecuted.


These aren't instructions; they're announcements that God's favor is already resting on exactly the people the empire has written off. So if God has already announced it, what's left for us to do? The answer is simple, though not easy: treat the blessed as blessed. God has already told us who they are, and our job is to stop treating them like they're not.


That can stay abstract forever if we let it, so let me get specific.


Blessed are the poor in spirit. Since last summer, more than three and a half million people have come off SNAP, and at the end of this year new Medicaid work and paperwork requirements take effect, which the Congressional Budget Office expects will cost more than five million people their coverage, largely through administrative failure rather than any change in whether they work.


Blessed are those who mourn. Nearly a million people have been deported in eighteen months, most of them with no criminal conviction, and two American citizens were killed by federal agents in Minneapolis.

Blessed are the meek, for they will inherit the earth. In January, the United States formally withdrew from the Paris climate agreement.


Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness. On his first day in office, the President pardoned roughly 1,500 people charged in the attack on the Capitol, including people convicted of assaulting police officers.


The first four Beatitudes tell us who God stands with. The rest tell us who God calls us to be. So how are we doing?

Blessed are the merciful. USAID has been dismantled, and a study in The Lancet projects up to fourteen million additional deaths by 2030 if the cuts stand, four and a half million of them children under five.


Blessed are the peacemakers. Since September of last year, U.S. military strikes on small boats in the Caribbean and the Pacific have killed more than 240 people, with no charges and no trial. Some of their families say they were fishermen.


Blessed are the persecuted. The refugee ceiling for this year is 17,500, down from 125,000 two years ago.

These are the people Jesus called blessed, and the people he calls us to be. This is what's being done to them, and in our name.


Are we treating the blessed as blessed? Right now, as a nation, we are not.


There are serious counterarguments here, and they deserve to be named honestly. A nation has a legitimate interest in its borders, and the rule of law is one of the ways a society protects the vulnerable from the powerful. Work carries real dignity, and public programs ought to be run with integrity, because every dollar lost to waste is a dollar not spent on someone in need. A chaotic border serves smugglers, not migrants; programs riddled with error lose public trust, and the poor are the first to pay. And many who voted for the current administration live in towns that both parties left behind decades ago. These are complex, nuanced issues where the law is concerned.


But Scripture does not set law against love; it sets law in the service of love. In his letter to the church in Rome, in the very chapter so often quoted to demand obedience to government, Paul says it plainly: love does no wrong to a neighbor; love is the fulfilling of the law. And Jesus, in this same Gospel, names the stranger among the least of these: I was a stranger, and you welcomed me.


Scripture doesn't hand us an immigration policy, and faithful Christians can disagree about how many refugees to admit and on what terms. What it does settle is the manner in which a nation carries out its laws. A nation should wield its laws in a spirit of justice, and it should never enforce them as though the people in its way don't bear the image of God.


The people who wave the Bible loudest in our public life rarely quote the Beatitudes, so let me say this as clearly as I can. When anyone takes the name of Jesus (this Jesus, sitting on that hillside) and uses it to bless policies that grind down the very people he called blessed, they've lost the plot. It's not for me to say they have ceased to be Christians, but they are failing at it, badly and publicly.


Here's the rub: I fail at it too, and so do you. Every one of us falls short, which is why we engage in the hard work of repentance. The difference isn't between Christians who fail and Christians who don't. It's between those who fail and repent, and those who call that failure faithfulness to God. That's what Christian nationalism does: it takes our failure to love the neighbor and baptizes it.


No political party is the Kingdom of God, not theirs and not mine.


So when someone says, "Both parties are corrupt, so I'm sitting this one out," I'll grant the first half. Both are compromised; welcome to politics, and to being human.


But compromised is not the same as equivalent. Staying home isn't neutrality. It's a choice, and the one who stays home isn't the one who pays for it. The hungry pay, the refugee pays, and the family waiting for a parent who isn't coming back pays.


So, Tuesday. Take your ballot in one hand and this Gospel in the other, and for every race, ask one question: Which of these choices treats the people Jesus called blessed as blessed? Which one treats them as a line item to be cut? You're smart people, and I trust you to do that math.


Voting isn't the whole of loving our neighbor; it isn't even most of it. That happens every day, at the food pantry and the hospital bed and the dinner table. But it is not nothing, because for some of our neighbors it's the difference between life and death.


So vote on Tuesday like the blessed are counting on it, because many of them are. And every day after that, treat the blessed as blessed.


Amen.



Sources